Journal of Harbin Institute of Technology  2017, Vol. 24 Issue (1): 32-36  DOI: 10.11916/j.issn.1005-9113.15176
0

Citation 

Yuchen Zhao,Yanjun Xu,Changzheng Chen,Fan Zhang,Jianyue Ren. Optical Design and Stray Light Analysis of the Space Infrared Optical System[J]. Journal of Harbin Institute of Technology, 2017, 24(1): 32-36. DOI: 10.11916/j.issn.1005-9113.15176.

Fund

Sponsored by the National High Technology Research and Development Program of China (Grant No.863-2-5-1-13B)

Corresponding author

Yuchen Zhao, E-mail: bernard19@163.com

Article history

Received: 2015-06-26
Optical Design and Stray Light Analysis of the Space Infrared Optical System
Yuchen Zhao1,2, Yanjun Xu1, Changzheng Chen1, Fan Zhang1, Jianyue Ren1     
1. Changchun Institute of Optics, Fine Mechanics and Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Changchun 130033, China;
2. University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China
Abstract: This article describes a novel configuration design for a re-imaging off-axis catadioptric space infrared optical system, and in order to satisfy the signal noise ratio requirements of the system, the stray light of the system is necessary to analyze and restrain. The optical system with a focal length of 1 200 mm, an entrance pupil diameter of 600 mm, an F-number of 2, a field of view of 3°×0.15°, a working wave band of 8 μm-10 μm, and the image quality of the optical system almost approach to diffraction limits in all field of view. Then the mathematical models of stray light are built, and the suppressive structure is established to eliminate the effect of stray light. Finally, TracePro is used to analyze and simulate stray light with and without the suppressive structure, and also get the results of the PST curves. The results indicate that appropriate optical system and suppressive structure can highly reduce the stray light of the space infrared optical system.
Key words: space infrared optical system     off-axis optical system     stray light     Point Source Transmission (PST)    
1 Introduction

Over the past decades, space research in the form of earth observation has required for a compact and lightweight optical system with a large field of view, and also generated stringent stray light control requirements, that makes the off-axis catadioptric optical system (OCOS) get greatly improvement. The OCOS has the following features: unobscured; easy to be lightweight; has better tolerance in the heat deformation; more design freedom; and can install field stop and multiple Lyot stop to restrain the stray light[1-4].

Stray light is the unwanted light reaching the focal plane array (FPA) during the operation of the infrared optical system, namely, it will create additional signal which can decrease the system's sensitivity, and will reduce the contrast of image, Modulation Transfer Function (MTF) and the Signal Noise Ratio (SNR)[5]. Hence, the suppression of stray light has become the key factor in the space optical system. In the 19th century, some institutions have developed a vast variety of software to model and simulate the stray light, such as GUERAPⅢ, APART/PADE, LightTools, TracePro, OptiCAD and so on[6-7]. At present, the main method of analyzing stray light is the method of modeling and simulating. This method is prevalently adopted to analyze the stray light, and with this method, it cannot only get the numerical value of the stray light, but also can render a visualized information of critical surfaces[8]. As a result, this method has become the main approach to study the stray light, moreover, the results of the simulation are taken as a guideline to design the suppressive structure of the optical system.

2 Optical Design

There are several types of configuration for realization of an infrared observation in the space. The different types can be divided into two main categories, namely, coaxial and non-coaxial systems. This article chooses non-coaxial system as the optical configuration of the system due to the following reasons: (1) without a central obstruction caused by its secondary mirror it will get a smaller diffraction pattern; (2) get a smaller size of baffle; (3) it is easy to get a larger FOV in the sagittal plane; (4) get a better image contrast and quality[9-12].

Fig. 1 shows the system configuration of the optical system, which consists of a Cook type off-axis three-mirror-anastigmatic system (TMAS), a folding mirror, a lens group and a flat FPA. The layout of the system is shown in Fig. 1, and its main specification is listed in Table 1.

Figure 1 Layout of the optical system

Table 1 Main specification of the system

The TMAS provides an obstruction-free aperture, high spatial resolution over a wide FOV and free of chromatic aberrations[13-15]. It consists of a concave primary mirror, a convex secondary mirror, a concave tertiary mirror and the aperture stop is located 60 mm before the primary mirror. All reflective mirrors share a common optical axis, although their mechanical axes are different from each other. The primary and tertiary mirror are ellipsoid, and the secondary mirror is a hyperboloid. The re-imaging plane is located between the the secondary and tertiary mirror. Table 2 summarizes the fundamental parameters of the TMAS.

Table 2 Parameters of the TMAS

The illustration of the relay lens group with the superimposed optical ray-trace is shown in Fig. 2. The material of the third lens is ZnSe, and the others are Germanium. The whole relay lens group has a 6° tilt about X axis, and a -117.6 mm decenter about Y axis. This is for connecting between the relay lens group and real exit pupil of the system. And it provides obstruction free aperture with one hundred percent cold stop efficiency to suppress shading of the infrared image.

Figure 2 Layout of the lens group

After optimization, the image quality of the optical system almost approach to the diffraction-limits in all FOV. The MTF and the spot diagram are shown in Fig. 3.

Figure 3 The MTF and spot diagram of the system

Optical design and optimization is substantial, but it is far from having a practicable infrared optical system. Therefore, the stray light must be analyzed and the suppressive structure must be designed to satisfy the requirements of image quality.

3 Evaluation Criterion of Stray Light 3.1 Stray Light Analysis

The power of the stray light which is received by the FPA depends on the following equation[16-18]:

$ {\mathit{\Phi }_{{\rm{FPA}}}} = {\mathit{\Phi }_{{\rm{source}}}} \times {f_{{\rm{GCF}}}}\left( {S,F} \right) \times {f_{{\rm{BRDF}}}} \times \pi $ (1)

where ΦFPA is the stray light power received by the FPA; Φsource is the power of the source; fGCF(S, F) is the geometrical configuration factor, which represents the geometrical nexus between the source and the FPA; fBRDF is the bidirectional distribution function, which represents the surface scattering characteristics. According to Eq.(1), the ways to reduce the energy of stray light is to decrease fGCF(S, F) of the system.

3.2 Mathematical Models of Stray Light

In general, the stray light contamination at a pixel is required to be less than 10% of the target irradiance to make sure that the SNR satisfies the requirement of image quality. For the earth observation space-borne infrared telescope, the useful signal is mainly from a narrow wavelength spectrum of thermal emission from the target. The infrared telescope that involved in this context, which has an extraordinarily small angle between optical axis and the earth's horizon, thus the external stray light is mainly from the out-of-field radiation of the earth.

This article uses Point Source Transmission (PST) as the evaluation criterion of the stray light, it represents the capability of the optical system to restrain the stray light[8-9]. The expression of PST is as Eq.(2):

$ {S_{{\rm{PST}}}} = \frac{{{E_d}\left( \theta \right)}}{{{E_i}\left( \theta \right)}} $ (2)

where Ed(θ) is the irradiance at the FPA; Ei(θ) is the irradiance at the entrance pupil, and θ is the off-field angle.

The average irradiance at the entrance pupil can be obtained by Eq.(3):

$ {E_i}\left( \theta \right) = {L_e}{\mathit{\Omega }_e}\cos {\theta _e} $ (3)

where Ei(θ) is the average irradiance at the entrance pupil; Le is the earth's radiance in the specified wavelength; Ωe is the solid angle between the earth and the entrance pupil; θe is the angle between the earth and the entrance pupil.

The radiant of the target at the FPA, namely, φtd can be expressed by Eq.(4):

$ {\varphi _{{\rm{td}}}} = \frac{{\rm{ \mathsf{ π} }}}{4}{L_e}A{\Omega _t}{\tau _0}\cos \left( {{\theta _t}} \right){\left( {\frac{D}{f}} \right)^2} $ (4)

where A is the area of the target; Ωt is the solid angle between the target and the entrance pupil; τ0 is the total transmittance of optical system; θt is the angle between the optical axis and the line that connecting the center of the target and the entrance pupil (θt is extremely small, so cos (θt) is approximately equal to 1); D is the diameter of the entrance pupil; f is the effective focal length.

Considering the actual image process, as the center of the image spot hardly coincides with one single pixel, therefore, an area of 2×2 pixels is regularly taken into account during the calculation. So the irradiance of the target at the FPA is as Eq.(5):

$ {E_{{\rm{td}}}} = \frac{{{\varphi _{{\rm{td}}}}}}{{4\alpha }} $ (5)

where Etd is the irradiance of the target at the FPA; α is the area of one single pixel. Through the above analysis, it can be obtained that Ed(θ)≤0.1Etd.

4 Stray Light Analyzing 4.1 Suppressive Structure Design

The suppressive structure includes baffles, vanes and stops.These are mechanical structures which can block the propagating path of the unwanted light.

The function of the baffle is to minimize stray light which has a large field angle. Vanes are the structure which are used to weaken the power of stray light, and force the stray light reflect several times before leaving the baffle[3]. Due to the strip FOV of the system, the shape of the vane is similar to rectangular as presented in Fig. 4(a), and the depth of the first vane is 118 mm, the width of the vane is 220 mm, and the bevel angle of the vane is 45°, which is shown in Fig. 4(b).

Figure 4 Vanes design

Stop is one of the most effective methods to restrain the stray light. In the optical system designed above, there are four types of stop which can be adopted, namely, aperture stop, field stop, Lyot stop and cold stop (coinciding with real exit pupil, and locating among the lens group). The folding mirror is behind the optical aperture which is on the supportive structure of the primary mirror, some stray light have direct view from the entrance pupil to the folding mirror. To avoid this stray light, four internal occulters are placed inside the optical system. More details is shown in Fig. 5.

Figure 5 Layout of suppressive structure of the optical system

4.2 Stray Light Analysis

In order to analyze the stray light and the suppressive structure designed, two detailed models are established in TracePro. One is the model ofoptical system with whole suppressive structure, and the other is the model of optical system with merely the supportive structure of the primary mirror. The surface in TracePro is defined by ABg model of the BRDF[18-20]:

1) Reflective mirror surface (SiC): λ=10 μm, r≥95%, in BRDF model A=0.001 5, B=0.001 4, g=1.8;

2) Refractive mirror surface: λ=10 μm, τ≥95%, in BRDF model A=1E-5, B=0.015, g=2, in BTDF model A=0.000 1, B=0.015, g=2;

3) Mechanical surface (coating with black paint Z-306): α=93%, r≥2%, in BRDF model A=0.636 6, B=0.015, g=2.

4) Focal plane: α=100%. where r is the reflectivity; τ is the transmittance and α is the absorptivity.

This article analyzes and contrasts the PSTs of the two models. The detailed PSTs for different incident angles are calculated, and the PST curves as shown in Fig. 6.

Figure 6 PST curve of the system

According to Figs. 6(a) and 6(b), with the increase of off-field angle, the PST of the optical system decreases. In the X direction, the structure and the FOV of the system is symmetric, the PST curve decreases in both directions, between 10° and 40° the PST decreases quickly, at off-field angle 3°, the PST of the first model arrives at 10-5, while the first is 1-4 order higher than the second model. In the Y direction, the system is asymmetric, and between the off-field angle of 10°-30° the PST curve of -Y direction is higher than +Y direction, which is caused by the configuration of the system, and it is evident that the first model is 1-4 order higher than the second. In Fig. 5, the fluctuations between off-angle 15° and 40° are obvious which are caused by the stray light incidence onto the FPA after several reflections between the baffle and vanes. The analysis of the two models demonstrates that the stray light simulation and analysis is an effective approach to guide the suppressive structure design of the infrared optical system.

5 Conclusions

This article presents the design of a re-imaging off-axis catadioptric optical system, and the image quality of the system almost approaches to diffraction limits in all fields of view. Due to its unique features, the system has been widely used in the space telescopes. Then the mathematical models of stray light is built, and the suppressive structure is established to eliminate the effect of stray light. And based on optical simulations by the stray light analysis software TracePro, which can fully describe the geometries and surface's properties of the system, the results indicate that the suppressive structure of the optical system has excellent ability to restrain the stray light, and decreases the PST of the optical system approximately 1 to 4 orders. At the same time, the calculated and simulated results can be a reference for system design.

References
[1] Geyl R. Design and fabrication of a three mirror flat field anastigmatic for high resolution earth observation. Proc. SPIE, 1994, 2210: 739-746. (0)
[2] Mazzoli A, Landini F, Vives S, et al. Stray light analysis and optimization of the ASPIICS/PROBA-3 formation flying solar coronagraph. Proc. of SPIE, 2014, 7731: 773146. (0)
[3] Stauder John L. Stray Light Comparison of Off-Axis and On-Axis Telescopes. Utah: Utah State University, 2000. 3-9. (0)
[4] Sha Wei, Chen Changzheng, Xu Yanjun, et al. Integrated primary and tertiary mirror components from common base line of off-axis TMA space camera. Optics and Precision Engineering, 2015, 23(6): 1612-1619. DOI:10.3788/OPE. (0)
[5] Gao Guopeng. The study of Suppressing Stray Light in Two-Mirror Optical System. Xi'an: Xi'an Institute of Optics and Precision Mechanics of Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2009.1-9. (in Chinese) (0)
[6] Du Shenhua, Xia Xinlin, Sun Chuang. Analysis on stray radiation of multi-spectral infrared remote sensor. Acta Photonica Sinica, 2008, 37(4): 763-767. (0)
[7] Lin Jianchun, Sun Liwan, Chen Boyang, et al. Stray light analysis of a coaxial two reflect mirror system and optimized design of inner photomask. Chinese Journal of Lasers, 2013, 40(1): 0116001. DOI:10.3788/CJL (0)
[8] Niu Jinxing, Shi Shuheng, Zhou Renkui. Analysis to stray radiation of infrared detecting system. Proc. of SPIE, 2011, 8193: 8193H. (0)
[9] Chang Jun, Weng Zhicheng, Cong Xiaojie. Design of compact, high-resolution optical system for space and Analyze stray light. Proc. SPIE, 2002, 4927: 0277786X. (0)
[10] Shi Guanwei, Zhang Xin, Zhang Jianping. Unobscured catadioptric infrared optical systems. Optics and Precision Engineering, 2014, 22(8): 1995-2000. DOI:10.3788/OPE. (0)
[11] Fischer R E. Optical System Design. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2008: 213-258. (0)
[12] Yu Linyao, Wei Qun, Zhang Xin, et al. Design of compact integral structure of two-mirror system. Optics and Precision Engineering, 2013, 21(3): 561-566. DOI:10.3788/OPE. (0)
[13] Pan Junhua. The methodic design of the IR imaging system with large aperture. Acta Optica Sinica, 2003, 23(12): 1475-1478. (0)
[14] Lu Haiping, Yuan Xiangyan, Zhang Kaiyuan. Infrared background radiation removing design and simulation of antarctic survey telescope. Acta Optica Sinica, 2014, 34(11): 1122002. DOI:10.3788/AOS (0)
[15] Zhang Junqiang, Wu Qingwen, Yan Changxiang. Stray light measurement technologies for space-borne imaging spectrometer. Chinese Journal of Optics, 2010, 3(4): 337-342. (0)
[16] Li Yan, Liu Jianfeng. Research on integrative suppression of internal and external stray light in infrared optical remote sensor. Acta Optica Sinica, 2013, 33(9): 0928002. DOI:10.3788/AOS (0)
[17] Lampton Michael L, Sholl Michael J, Levi Michael E. Off-axis telescopes for dark energy investigations. Proc. of SPIE, 2010, 7731: 77311G. DOI:10.1117/12.856500 (0)
[18] Wang Lei, Ma Wenli. Stray light suppression of optical and mechanical system for optical system detection. Proc. of SPIE, 2013, 8907: 89070H. DOI:10.1117/12.2030820 (0)
[19] Li Da, Liu Peng, Chen Bin, et al. Stray light analysis and experimental verification of spherical reflective coronagraph experimental devices. Optics and Precision Engineering, 2015, 23(5): 1265-1270. DOI:10.3788/OPE.20152305.1265.(inChinese) (0)
[20] Zhong Xing, Jia Jiqiang. Stray light removing design and simulation of spaceborne camera. Optics and Precision Engineering, 2009, 17(3): 621-625. (0)