doi: 10.11916/j.issn.1005-9113.2025014
Regular and Singular Components of 2D Periodic FluidFlows on a Surface of Viscous Stratified Fluid
1. Ishlinsky Institute for Problems in Mechanics of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow 119526 , Russia
2. Faculty of Physics and Techology,Yaroslavl State University, Yaroslavl 150003 , Russia
Funds: Sponsored by Ministry of Science and Higher Education within the Framework of Russian State Assignment(Grant No.124012500442-3).
Abstract
The modern definition of the wave concept, which is based on the functional connection between the parameters of the spatial structure of an instantaneous flow pattern and the characteristics of the temporal variability at a given point, is discussed. The dispersion relation for 2D plane periodic perturbations on the surface of viscous stratified fluid is selected as the characteristic function defining the wave motion. Using the theory of singular perturbations, a method for calculating complete solutions to the dispersion relations of periodic flows, including regular wave and singular ligament solutions is presented. Properties of the complete exact solution of the dispersion relation containing regular and singular functions are compared with asymptotic solutions. In limiting cases, obtained dispersion relations are matched with well-known expressions for waves in homogeneous viscous and ideal liquids.
0 Introduction
Waves have been observed on the surface of natural reservoirs, both small ponds and the boundless world ocean since time immemorial. However, it was only at the beginning of the19th century that they became the subject of rigorous mathematical analysis, with the publication of Ref.[1]. The results of this work continued to be actively discussed and further developed in Ref.[2].
The observations of Franklin[3], who pointed out the importance of taking heterogeneity into account when studying fluid vibrations, were developed in works on the theoretical study of wave motions in a liquid layer of inhomogeneous density[4-5], in relation to the dynamics of an heterogeneous atmosphere[6-7]. The laboratory modelling of the “dead water” effect noticed by Nansen in Norwegian fjords and the Kara Sea was performed as well[8]. The results of the mathematical determination of buoyancy frequency, the frequency of natural fluctuations of displaced volume in stratified media, determined the frequency range for traveling internal waves[9], which received limited attention of researchers at the beginning of the20th century. This loss led to an experimental redefinition of buoyancy frequency based on observations of probe ball movements[10] and atmospheric pressure microfluctuations[11]. However, the approximation of homogeneous medium, which was accepted in Ref.[1], was saved in subsequent studies on waves on the liquid surface performed in the19th and the20th centuries[12-13].
A large number of studies on traveling linear and nonlinear waves were based on the Euler equations[14]. The effect of internal friction was taken into account by introducing additional terms into the equations of motion[15-16]. It was partially considered in the theory of wave propagation by introducing a dissipative term (including kinematic viscosity) in the solutions of the ideal fluid equations of motion[9].
The interest in the detailed study of processes in the stratified ocean and atmosphere, which emerged in the second half of the20th century, led to the expansion of the class of waves being investigated with different dispersion laws. This included not only surface waves, but also internal, inertial, and hybrid waves in both neutral and charged fluids[17-19]. In the 20th century, new methods for their mathematical description evolved. The important components of wave theory were the construction methods and the investigation of the properties of dispersion relations, which are functionally related to the physically observable parameters of plane waves (period and wavelength) , or their spectral counterparts (frequency and wave number) in linear and nonlinear approximations[20].
The results of wave observations in configuration space are normally described using real numbers. In order to derive the dispersion relations, the problem is submerged into the algebra of complex numbers, where both the frequency ω and wave vector k are typically chosen to be complex. This expansion of the mathematical formulation results in the appearance of more complicated mathematical quantities (the observed scalar wavelength correlates with a three-dimensional wave vector) and in the redundant solutions that are rejected based on physical criteria. Additionally, this approach leads to an increase in the number of methods available for analyzing the problem, including the calculations of flow stability[21].
In practice, a partial analysis of the problem is also carried out along with the general approach. The frequency indicating the energy is kept real, and the wave vector is chosen as a complex number[22]. This means that the wavelength is determined by both the real and imaginary parts of the wave vector, and the wave attenuation is described by the imaginary component of the wave vector as it propagates. When studying waves in a weakly viscous liquid, such as water, where the system of governing equations contains small coefficients with higher derivatives, the methods of the theory of singular perturbations are used to find the solution to the system of equations[23-24]. Viscous stratified fluid flows have a large number of intrinsic eigenscale time and length scales, both in the general case and in specific tasks. The ratios of the eigenscales define the small parameters of the problem, and the traditional dimensionless numbers, that are the Reynolds, Froude, Weber numbers, and others[25].
Modern researchers often resort to numerical methods when solving problems involving complex fluid flows, such as the flow of hybrid nanofluids over a rotating surface accounting for thermal radiation and electromagnetic field effects[26], flows in porous media[27], and magnetohydrodynamic flows of nanofluids[28].In Refs. [29]-[31], the influence of external factors such as magnetic field and medium porosity on enhancing heat transfer using nanofluids is investigated.
The modern definition of the wave concept is based on the functional connection between the parameters of the spatial structure of an instantaneous flow pattern and the characteristics of the temporal variability at a given point[22]. This connection is described by the dispersion relation. Its type depends on the physical parameters of the problem and the boundary conditions. The regular parts of the complete dispersion relations for periodic flows in a viscous continuously stratified fluid describe various types of waves (acoustic, gravitational, surface, internal and hybrid type) . The regular components of the complete solution characterize waves that determine the geometry of the perturbed surface. Natural physical constraints define the acceptable direction of wave propagation.
The singular components define “ligaments”[25] describing the fine structure of the heterogeneous medium. They are ubiquitously manifested in the form of thin fibers and interfaces, which differ from a more homogeneous surrounding medium in their properties. The term “ligaments” was borrowed by Rayleigh[32] from medicine, where it refers to various types of connective tissues, such as “shells”, “fascia”, “fibers” and more than 30 other types, which are the synonyms of this term in this context.
The general approach allows us to take into account both the influence of gravity and the action of fields of a different physical nature. In particular, the effect of the surface electric charge on the characteristics of all components of periodic flows on the surface of a perturbed liquid is estimated in Ref.[25].
Given the prevalence of regular perturbations on the liquid surface and the scientific and particularly applied significance of studying them, it is important to describe the properties of all components of periodic flows and evaluate the completeness of the solutions obtained and the accuracy of the expressions received. This paper presents a methodology for creating and analyzing the properties of a complete solution of the dispersion relation for periodic (or monochromatic) infinitesimal flows on the surface of a viscous, stably stratified liquid in a gravitational field. It also considers the effects of surface tension and compares the properties of the exact and approximate asymptotic solutions of the dispersion equation. The proposed methodology allows new complete solutions of the dispersion relations, including known regular formulaem, to be obtained. The singular components of periodic flows describe ligaments determining the fine structure of periodic flows. The paper considers the application of the technique in relation to periodic surface disturbances in uniformly stratified viscous liquids with frequencies in the range of 0.01 s-1ω< 1000 s-1.
1 Mathematical Formulation of the Problem
Due to the heterogeneity in the distribution of pressure, temperature, concentration of dissolved substances and suspended particles both liquids in natural reservoirs and the World Ocean and the atmosphere turn out to be stably stratified in the field of gravity. The stability of stratification, which is determined by the density distribution ρ (z) with height z, and characterized by the length scale Λ=|dlnρ (z) /dz|-1, the buoyancy frequency N=g/Λ, and the period Tb=2π/N of buoyancy, appears to be heterogeneous. Relatively thick and more homogeneous layers with thin ligaments separated by thin highly gradient interfaces are distinguished in the profiles[33-34].
The complete system of equations for the mechanics of inhomogeneous fluids, which includes the continuity equations, the equations of transfer of momentum, total energy, and matter, as well as the closed equation of state with physically justified initial and boundary conditions[17-19, 22], is rather complex. That is why it would be advisable to start the development of methods for creating complete solutions, which describe infinitesimal periodic flows with the analysis of reduced models that enable the creation of complete solutions. One of these models is a system of motion equations for density-stratified fluids that do not contain additional physical variables describing fluid density distributions. This approach is often used to simplify calculations and reduce the number of variables when analyzing fluctuations and waves in liquids[17, 35]. Additionally, it is assumed that the effects of compressibility can be neglected and an additional condition divu =0 can be introduced for velocity u.
The study of waves in heterogeneous fluids is carried out in the Cartesian coordinate system Oxyz. The Oz axis is directed vertically upward against the direction of gravity acceleration g. Perturbations of the free surface z=ζ (x, t) propagating in the positive direction of the horizontal axis Ox, which coincides with the equilibrium position of the free surface of the liquid, are considered.
The variable density of a liquid, which is used without specifying the physical nature of its change, is traditionally divided into two terms:
ρ(x,z,t)=ρ00[r(z)+ρ~(x,z,t)]=ρ00exp-zΛ+ρ~(x,z,t)
(1a)
zΛ=z/Λ
(1b)
Here t denotes time variable, zΛ is a dimensionless parameter characterizing the ratio of the current coordinate to the stratification scale Λ-the value of the depth at which the density increases by e times where “e” means Euler's number. The first term of Eq.1 (a) describes an unperturbed density distribution with height, an exponential distribution r (z) =exp (-zΛ) is chosen to simplify the calculations, and P~ is a small density disturbance associated with the propagation of a periodic surface flow, ρ00 is the equilibrium density value at z=0.
The pressure in a liquid P=P (x, z, t) is written as the sum of atmospheric P00, hydrostatic and periodic pressure perturbation P~ (x, z, t) :
P=P00+zζ gρ(x,ξ,t)dξ+P~(x,z,t)
(2)
Here g denotes free fall acceleration, and ξ is the integration variable. Taking into account the simplifications, the mathematical formulation of the problem determines the dispersion characteristics, velocity field, momentum, and pressure in the fluid, which determines the dynamics and structure of periodic motion, consists of the Navier-Stokes and continuity equations, supplemented by physically justified boundary conditions on the free surface of the liquid, kinematic and dynamic boundary conditions:
z<ζ:ρtu+(u)u=ρνΔu-P+ρgtρ+uρ=0divu=0
(3)
z=ζ:t(z-ζ)+u(z-ζ)=0τ((n)u)+n((τ)u)=0P-P0-σdivn-2ρνn((n)u)=0
(4)
z=-:u=(u,w)(0,0)
(5)
n= (z-ζ) | (z-ζ) |=-xζex+ez1+xζ2
τ=ex+xζez1+xζ2
where n, τ are the vectors of the external normal and tangent to the free surface of the liquid, respectively, and u = (u, w) defines the velocity field in the liquid column caused by a surface disturbance.
Let us accept some conventional simplifications for this type of problem, namely the Boussinesq approximation. In the case of small amplitude deviations of the free surface, the Boussinesq approximation is applied when the density is assumed to be constant in terms with small coefficients. In this case, the density variability is taken into account only for terms containing a large coefficient (the gravity acceleration in the Navier-Stokes equation and the density gradient in the continuity equation) . In the two-dimensional formulation, the velocity components can be expressed in terms of a single scalar stream function ψ:
u=(u,w)=zψ,-xψ
(6)
Also, in the case of infinitesimal deviations, a well-known procedure, namely the domain perturbation method, is performed for the displacement of boundary conditions from the wave surface to the equilibrium surface[36]. Then taking into account Eq. (6) and the accepted simplifications in a linear approximation, Eqs. (3) - (5) can be shown as follows:
z < 0 : ρ 00 g z ζ x ρ ~ ( x , χ , t ) d χ + ρ 00 g x ζ ν ρ 00 z Δ ψ + ρ 00 z t ψ + x P ~ = 0 ν ρ 00 x Δ ψ ρ 00 x t ψ + z P ~ = 0 t ρ ~ + exp z Λ x ψ Λ = 0
(7)
z = 0 : z z ψ x x ψ = 0 P ~ + σ x x ζ + 2 ν ρ z x ψ = 0 t ζ + x ψ = 0
(8)
z=-:zψ,-xψ(0,0)
(9)
Eqs. (7) - (9) are written for values of the first order of smallness of each unknown function. To maintain accuracy, over-estimation is usually introduced and all unknown quantities in Eqs. (7) - (9) should additionally be marked with a subscript “1” indicating the order of magnitude, which is omitted to avoid cumbersome formula.
When performing mathematical calculations, it is often necessary to take into account the incompressibility condition. Besides the stream function, a hydrodynamic potential is also introduced, assuming that the motion is potential. However, surface waves in stratified fluids lose their potential property due to baroclinic generation of vorticity[13]. The vorticity of these waves in stratified media is non-zero. When viscosity is regarded, additional terms appear in the mathematical formulation, which are responsible for generating vorticity in surface periodic flows[37]. Due to these observations, it becomes impossible to use velocity recordings through the hydrodynamic potential in the mathematical formulation of the given problem, as the solution quality is lost.
2 Solution of Linearized Problem
For surface periodic flows, the solution is sought in the form of harmonic functions:
f(x,z,t)Aexpikxx+kzz-iωt
(10)
Substituting Eq. (10) into Eq. (7) , we obtain a dispersion relation connecting the components of the wave vector k = (kx, kz) with the frequency of wave motion ω:
ωkx2-kz2iνkx2-iνkz2+ω-
N2kx2exp-zΛ=0
(11)
The proposed approach is based on the assumption that the frequency ω>0 is positive, as the parameter describes the energy of periodic flow. The components of k = (kx, kz) can be complex, and it can describe spatial attenuation of periodic disturbances.
It is convenient to analyze the dispersion relation Eq. (11) in a dimensionless form and to select eigenscale parameters as dimensionless values. The model easily identifies its spatial and temporal scales: viscous length scale δNgν= (gν) 1/3N-1, buoyancy frequency N, buoyancy period Tb, stratification scale Λ, Stokes microscales for buoyancy δNν=ν/N and wave δνω=ω/ν frequencies, and capillary length γgδ=γ/g.. The intrinsic scales determine the characteristic sizes and lifetimes of the flow components in a liquid, which can vary widely. For example, the spatial parameters of water can vary from fractions of centimeters to meters, both in laboratory and natural conditions. In this study, the values in Eq. (11) will become dimensionless. The inverse buoyancy frequency τN=N-1 will be the time scale and the viscous length scale δNgν=gν3/N will be the spatial scale. The dimensionless form of the dispersion relation Eq. (11) is written as:
iεk*x2-k*z22ω*+k*x2-k*z2ω*2-k*x2exp-zΛ=0
(12)
where, the subscript “*” indicates the corresponding dimensionless values. With this choice of dimensionless parameters, the parameter ε=δgν/δNgν=Nν1/3/g2/3 arises naturally in the problem defined by Eqs. (7) - (9) , determined by the ratio of the natural scales of the medium. In a wide class of fluids, either the buoyancy frequency N or the kinematic viscosity ν, or both of these parameters are small quantities simultaneously, and therefore, ε is a natural small parameter in the problem defined by Eqs. (7) - (9) .
To solve the dispersion relation Eq. (12) with respect to k*z, the asymptotic methods are used[23-24]. The regular decomposition of the components of the wave vector k*z with respect to the small parameter ε is written as:
k*z=k0+εk1+ε2k2+
(13)
Substitute Eq. (13) into Eq. (12) , we get:
iεk*x2-k0+εk1+ε2k2+22ω*+k*x2-k0+εk1+ε2k2+2ω*2-k*x2exp-zΛ=0
(14)
By opening the brackets and collecting the multipliers with the same degree of the small parameter, we rewrite the dispersion relation as follows:
k*x2-k02ω*-exp-zΛ+εik*x4-2ik*x2k02ω*-2k0k1ω*2+ik04ω*+ε2-4ik*x2k0k1ω*+4ik03k1ω*-k12ω*2-2k0k2ω*2+=0
(15)
By allocating the terms corresponding to the degrees of ε, it is possible to construct a system of equations for different orders of magnitude:
k x 2 k 0 2 ω exp z Λ = 0 i k x 4 2 i k x 2 k 0 2 ω 2 k 0 k 1 ω 2 + i k 0 4 ω = 0 4 i k x 2 k 0 k 1 ω + 4 i k 0 3 k 1 ω k 1 2 ω 2 2 k 0 k 2 ω 2 = 0
(16)
By sequentially solving equations from Eq. (16) , it is possible to obtain an approximate regular solution with any initially specified accuracy:
k0=±k*xω*2-exp-zΛω*
(17a)
k1=ik*x2-k022k0ω*=±ik*exp-zΛ2ω*2ω*2-exp-zΛ
(17b)
k2=k12ik0-k1ω*2k0ω*=k*xexp-zΛ-3exp-zΛ+4ω*28ω*2ω*2-exp-zΛω*2-exp-zΛ
(17c)
Eq. (17) contains two roots, but Eq. (12) is a fourth-order relative to k*z. Thus, using regular decompositions, we can only obtain a part of the solutions. It is worth noting that in the dispersion Eq. (12) , the small parameter ε stands at the highest power of k*z. For clarity, expand the brackets in Eq. (12) :
iεk*z4ω*+iεk*x4ω*2-2iεk*x2k*z2ω*-kz2ω*2+k*x2ω*2-exp-zΛk*x2=0
(18)
The equation belongs to the singularly perturbed equations[24], and the missing solutions can be found using the following singular expansions:
k*z=ε-ηk0+εk1+ε2k2+,η>0
(19)
To determine the value of the parameter η, we put the main term of the expansion into the dispersion Eq. (18) :
iε1-4ηk04ω*+iεk*x4ω*2-2iε1-2ηk*x2k02ω*-ε-2ηk02ω*2+k*x2ω*2-e-zΛk*x2=0
(20)
Following the procedure described in Ref.[24], we sequentially equate the degrees of the small parameter ε in different terms of Eq. (20) . As a result, the following relations arise for the variable η:
1-2η=1,1-2η=1-4η,1-2η=-2η,1-4η=1,1-4η=-2η,1-4η=0,-2η=1,-2η=0,1-2η=0
(21)
With possible solutions:
η=-12,η=0,η=14,η=12
(22)
From the obtained roots, the value of η is selected based on the following considerations. When η from Eq. (22) is substituted into Eq. (20) , it provides the main value for the term with the highest degree of k04. In this case, the values of η, which are less than or equal to zero, are not considered since in this case decomposition will be reduced to the regular one discussed above. After substitution and verification, we find that one root η=1/2 satisfies the specified conditions. The singular value decomposition is shown as follows:
k*z=ε-1/2k0+ε1/2k1+ε3/2k2+
(23)
Substituting Eq. (23) into Eq. (20) , by analogy with the regular decomposition, we obtain the system of equations for terms of different orders of smallness in ε:
k 0 2 k 0 2 + i ω = 0 i ω 2 k 0 k 1 k x 2 2 k 0 2 + i ω exp z Λ k x 2 = 0 6 k 0 2 k 1 2 + 4 k 0 3 k 2 4 k 0 k 1 k x 2 + i k 1 2 ω + 2 i k 0 k 2 ω + k x 4 = 0
(24)
The sequential solution of this system allows to obtain asymptotic singular solutions:
k0=±1-i2ω*
(25a)
k1=k*22ik02ω*-ω*2+exp-zΛ2k0ω*2ik02-ω*=
±(1+i)k*x2ω*2-exp-zΛ22ω*5/2
(25b)
It is worth noting that dispersion relation Eq. (12) allows constructing exact solutions in the model under consideration the following equations:
k*z=±k*x2-iω*2ε+i4iεk*x2exp-zΛ+ω*32εω*
(26)
k*l=±k*x2-iω*2ε-i4iεk*x2exp-zΛ+ω*32εω*
(27)
Eqs. (26) – (27) correspond to roots in the following dimensional variables:
kz=±kx2-iω2ν-(1-i)4kx2νωN2exp-zΛ-iω422νω
(28)
kl=±kx2-iω2ν+(1-i)4kx2νωN2exp-zΛ-iω422νω
(29)
where, k*l and kl are redefined for roots that correspond to singular asymptotic solutions to distinguish between regular and singular solutions. The proof of compliance is given below.
To identify the correspondence between the exact solutions Eqs. (26) – (27) and the asymptotic solutions Eqs. (17) and (25) , the root expression in Eqs. (26) – (27) in the Taylor series for the small parameter ε is as follows:
i4iεk*x2exp-zΛ+ω*32εω*iω*2ε-k*x2ω*2exp-zΛ
(30)
Substituting Eq. (30) into Eqs. (26) and (27) , we get:
k*z=±k*x2-iω*2ε+iω*2ε-k*x2ω*2exp-zΛ±k*xω*2-exp-zΛω*
(31)
k*l=±k*x2-iω*2ε-iω*2ε-k*x2ω*2exp-zΛ±1-i2εω*
(32)
It should be noted that the approximate expansions obtained from Eqs. (31) - (32) , exactly coincide with the first term of the asymptotic regular solution Eq. (24) and singular one Eq. (25) , respectively. In this sense, the exact roots of Eqs. (26) and (28) can be called regular, and the roots of Eqs. (27) and (29) can be called singular.
Thus, qualitatively new solutions appear in the viscous fluid model, which are described by singular components of dispersion relations. They characterize the fine structure of periodic flows, i.e. ligaments. Taking into account the wave and ligament components of the flow Eqs. (26) – (27) , the type of solution for the stream function ψ is written as follows:
ψ=Aexpkzz+Bexpklzexpikxx-iωt
(33)
From the compatibility of the boundary conditions Eq. (8) and the basic Eq. (7) , we obtain a dispersion equation connecting the component of the wave vector k x with the frequency ω. To do this, we exclude the free surface deviation function of the equilibrium value ζ from the equations using the cross derivative of the kinematic and dynamic boundary conditions. The periodic pressure perturbation P~ (x, z, t) is excluded due to the implication of the component of the Navier-Stokes Eq. (7) , and by substituting Eq. (33) , we obtain the following ratio[38]:
kx2+kz2klω2-gkx2-γkx4+iωνkl3kx2-kl2-kx2+kl2kzω2-gkx2-γkx4+iωνkz3kx2-kz2=0
(34)
The terms determined by gravity (proportional to gkx2) and the terms characterizing the effect of surface tension (proportional to γkx4) are easily distinguished in the dispersion relation Eq. (34) . Gravitational and capillary effects are often considered separately in practical problems. The dispersion equation becomes significantly simpler with these wavelength constraints. When both effects are taken into account, the dispersion Eq. (34) is not solved exactly analytically, but can be solved numerically using modern programs for symbolic calculations. The use of asymptotic methods allows approximate solutions to be obtained. The remaining boundary conditions allow us to determine the relationship between the amplitudes of the ligament and wave components of the stream function and the deviation of the free surface from the equilibrium position. In a dimensionless form, when ratios of the eigenscales are used as the dimensionless parameters, the ratio Eq. (34) is rewritten as follows:
k*x2+k*l2δ2εk*x4+iε2ω*k*zk*z2-3k*x2+k*x2-εk*zω*2-k*x2+k*z2δ2εk*x4+iε2ω*k*lk*l2-3k*x2+k*x2-εk*l2ω*2=0
(35)
whereδ=δgγ/δNν=Nγ/νgis a dimensionless parameter characterizing the ratio of the capillary length to the Stokes microscale. Substituting Eqs. (31) and (32) into Eq. (35) , we can obtain an approximate dispersion relation up to terms of the order of o (ε) :
k*xx1-i2εω*-k*xω*2-1ω*1-i2εω*k*x+ω*2-1ω*k*x2+1-i2δ2ω*k*x3-1-i2ω*3/2ω*2-1ε+k*x1-ω*2+δ2ω*2-1ω*k**x4ε=0
(36)
Reducing the approximate dispersion relation Eq. (36) to a dimensional form and simplifying the expression, we obtain:
kx-iω3+kx2νN2-ω2kx3γ+gkx-ωω2-N2=0
(37)
The roots of Eq. (37) are easy to find and take the values:
kx=0,kx=±(1+i)ω3/22νN2-ω2
(38)
kx=α1/332/321/3γ-21/3g31/3α1/3
(39)
kx=-(13i)α1/324/332/3γ+(1±3i)g22/331/3α1/3
(40)
α=9γ2ωω2-N2+3γ34g3+27γω2ω2-N2
The solutions of the dispersion equations must be provided with natural conditions for the physical realization of the roots. For surface periodic two-dimensional flows propagating in the positive direction of the Ox axis, the conditions for the physical feasibility of solutions are written as follows:
Rekx>0,Imkx>0,Rekz,l>0
(41)
The positivity condition of the imaginary part of the component kx is satisfied by Eqs. (39) and (38) . The remaining roots grow as the horizontal coordinate increases. When we substitute these expressions into Eqs. (26) - (27) , we find that only the solutions defined by the root of Eq. (39) exhibit a decrease with decreasing vertical coordinate.
To compare the solutions obtained using asymptotic methods with those from the numerical calculation of the dispersion equation, we construct the dispersion dependencies for the wave and segment components of the surface periodic flow in a fluid with water parameters σ=72×10-7 J/cm2, ρ00=1 g/cm3, g=981 cm/s2 for laboratory conditions (highly stratified liquid N=1 s-1) and for a stratified ocean (N=0.01 s-1) . We define the wavelength λ and the scale of the ligament δl as follows[38]:
λ=2πRekx2+Imkz2
δl=2πRekx2+Imkl2
The curves in Figs.1 (a) and 1 (b) are performed using the expressions (26) and analytical asymptotic Eq. (39) for analytical wavelength λa (ω) (solid lines) and obtained as a result of the direct numerical solution of the dispersion Eq. (34) for numerical wavelength λn (ω) (dashed lines) . Similar graphics are performed for analytical ligament scale δla (ω) Eqs. (27) and (39) (solid lines) and obtained as a result of the direct numerical solution of the dispersion Eq. (34) for numerical ligament scale δln (ω) (dashed lines) .
In Figs.1 (a) and (b) , the dependencies of the analytical asymptotic wavelength λa and numerical wavelength λn on the frequency of the periodic flow with insets of the region are constructed. The difference in surface periodic flows is most noticeable in a liquid where water parameters have different buoyancy frequencies. In Figs.1 (c) and (d) , the difference relative to the wavelength of λn between the analytical and numerical values of Δλ/λ=λa-λn/λn for different values of the buoyancy frequency is shown.
The analysis shows that the most noticeable difference between asymptotic and numerical values is achieved in the field of capillary-gravity waves. It takes values of the order of percent, starting from the frequency of 20 s-1, and grows with the increasing frequency up to values of the order of several tens of percent. As the frequency of periodic movement decreases, the relative difference decreases rapidly and amounts to fractions of a percent. As the periodic motion frequency approaches the buoyancy frequency, there is an increasing difference between the numerical and analytical asymptotic solution, which is more noticeable for liquids with lower buoyancy frequency values and does not exceed fractions of a percent. For a strongly stratified liquid, the analytical asymptotic value underestimates the wavelength compared with the numerical solution, while for a weakly stratified liquid, on the contrary, an over-estimation is observed. This is due to the presence of the buoyancy frequency in the small parameter ε and the discarding of some terms in asymptotic calculations.
Fig.1The dependence of the wavelength on the frequency of periodic motion obtained using analytical asymptotic methods λa and as a result of the numerical solution λn at: (a) N=1 s-1, (b) N=0.01 s-1 and the relative difference between numerical and analytical asymptotic expressions Δλ/λn at (c) N=1 s-1, (d) N=0.01 s-1
In Fig.2, which is similar to Fig.1, the dependencies for the ligament component of the flow are shown.Figs.2 (a) and (b) show the dependencies of the analytical δla and numerical δln ligament scale on frequency at different values of the buoyancy frequency. In Figs.2 (c) and (d) , the difference between the asymptotic and numerical values of Δδ1/δ1=δla-δln/δln relative to the numerical scale of the ligament δln is created. When calculating fine-structured ligaments, the difference is insignificant, and the analytical asymptotic expressions practically coincide with the numerical ones for the entire frequency range.
3 Limiting Transitions
Considering the transitions to the known limiting cases and observing the changes in the regular and singular components of the solution.
3.1 Homogeneous Viscous Fluid
The most common simplification in the theory of surface waves is to investigate the problem without taking into account density inhomogeneity, while considering the influence of viscosity. In a homogeneous liquid ρ=ρ00=const, Eqs. (2) - (5) becomes significantly simpler. The pressure distribution in a liquid can be determined by the following expression:
P=P00+ρ00g (ζ-z) +P~ (x, z, t)
The equation of continuity is automatically satisfied under the given simplifications. The basic equations of motion and the boundary conditions can be expressed as:
z<ζ:ρ00tu+ (u) u=ρ00νΔu-P+ρ00gdivu=0
Fig.2The dependence of the ligament scale on the frequency of periodic motion obtained using analytical asymptotic methods δla and as a result of the numerical solution δln at: (a) N=1 s-1, (b) N=0.01 s-1 and the relative difference between numerical and analytical asymptotic expressions Δδl/δl at (c) N=1 s-1, (d) N=0.01 s-1
z=ζ:t (z-ζ) +u (z-ζ) =0τ ( (n) u) +n ( (τ) u) =0P-P0-σdivn-2ρ00νn ( (n) u) =0
z=-:u= (u, w) (0, 0)
The expressions for the stream function take the form:
z < 0 : ρ 00 g x ζ ν ρ 00 z Δ ψ + ρ 00 z t ψ + x P ~ = 0 ν ρ 00 x Δ ψ ρ 00 x t ψ + z P ~ = 0
(42)
z = 0 : z z ψ x x ψ = 0 P ~ + σ x x ζ + 2 ν ρ 00 z x ψ = 0 t ζ + x ψ = 0
(43)
z=-:zψ, -xψ (0, 0)
By substituting Eq. (10) into the system (42) , we can obtain the dispersion relation that connects the components of the wave vector:
kx2-kz2iνkx2-iνkz2+ω=0
(44)
Solving Eq. (44) , we get the following roots:
kz=±kx,kl=±kx2-iων
(45)
Here the solution obtained using the theory of singular perturbations is reinterpreted (kl) by analogy with the previous item. Considering the roots of Eq. (45) , the solution for the stream function takes the form of Eq. (33) by analogy with the previous item. The dispersion relation comes from the compatibility condition between the boundary conditions and the basic Eqs. (42) - (43) . It provides the connection between the components of the wave vector, frequency, and other parameters in the problem. This formally looks identical to Eq. (34) .
kx2+kz2klω2-gkx2-γkx4+iωνkl3kx2-kl2-kx2+kl2kzω2-gkx2-γkx4+iωνkz3kx2-kz2=0
(46)
The solution of Eq. (46) can be obtained by taking into account Eq. (45) . It can be obtained either numerically or using analytical asymptotic methods. More details on the peculiarities of calculating dispersion relations in simplified models are discussed in Ref.[38].
Dispersion relations can be derived by performing the limiting transition N→0 (Λ) . The regular components of the flow determine large-scale waves as in a stratified fluid, while the singular components correspond to fine ligaments. However, the density of the medium is not considered in a homogeneous fluid model, therefore, the density gradient is equal to zero and it would not be correct to speak of ligament structures as high-gradient interfaces. Hence, the quality of singular components of the solution is lost in a homogeneous fluid model.
3.2 Ideal Stratified Fluid
When considering flows in the model of an ideal stratified fluid, the mathematical formulation of the problem can be written as:
z<ζ:ρtu+ (u) u=-P+ρgtρ+uρ=0divu=0
z=ζ:t (z-ζ) +u (z-ζ) =0P-P0-σdivn=0
z=-:u= (u, w) (0, 0)
The mathematical formulation of the problem takes the following form in a linear approximation when the stream function is applied:
z<0:ρ00gzζ xρ~(x,X,t)dX+ρ00gxζ+ρ00ztψ+xP~=0-ρ00xtψ+zP~=0tρ~+exp-zΛxψΛ=0
(47)
z=0:P~+σxζ=0tζ+xψ=0
z=-:zψ, -xψ (0, 0)
The substitution of Eq. (10) into the system (47) in an ideal stratified fluid results in the following dispersion equation:
kx2-kz2ω2-N2kx2exp-zΛ=0
(48)
The solution of Eq. (48) is written as:
kz=±kx1-N2ω2exp-zΛ
(49)
The classical relation that defines the connection between the components of the wave vector and the frequency of the wave is derived from the compatibility of the boundary conditions on the free surface and the basic equations of motion:
gkx2-ω2kz+γkx4=0
The rate of the system of equations describing the motion is reduced due to the disregard of viscosity in the basic equations. This results in a decrease of the order of dispersion equation, and the loss of some solutions, i.e. there are no singular roots in the ideal fluid model. Therefore, a whole class of solutions that describe structural components is lost in the problems involving the propagation of periodic flows due to the disregard of viscosity.
3.3 Ideal Homogeneous Fluid
The mathematical description in the ultimately reduced model of an ideal homogeneous fluid is expressed in the simplest terms as follows:
z<ζ:ρ00tu+ (u) u=-P+ρ00gdivu=0
z=ζ:t (z-ζ) +u (z-ζ) =0P-P0-σdivn=0
z=-:u= (u, w) (0, 0)
Using the stream function in a linear approximation, the mathematical formulation of the problem can be written as follows:
z<0:ρ00gxζ+ρ00ztψ+xP~=0-ρ00xtψ+zP~=0
z=0:P~+σxxζ=0tζ+xψ=0
z=-:zψ, -xψ (0, 0)
The dispersion relations in the model of an ideal homogeneous fluid are greatly simplified and include only the wave components of the periodic flow. Thus, the surface periodic flow is found to be potential in this model. Analogous expressions can be derived using the velocity potential u =φ.
kz=±kx,gkx2-ω2kz+γkx4=0
(50)
It is worth noting that the choice of the sign in Eqs. (45) , (49) , and (50) is made in accordance with the conditions for the physical realization of the roots Eq. (41) , for the reasons similar to those discussed in Section 2.
A highly simplified model leads to a straightforward solution that captures some trends in large-scale flow components, but it differs qualitatively from the solutions obtained in more complete formulations. The key difference is the absence of certain solutions that define the fine structure of periodic processes in continuous media.
4 Conclusions
The investigation of the linearized equations of motion for a heterogeneous viscous fluid shows the complexity of the dispersion relation, which forms the basis for distinguishing the wave motion from other types of flows. The high rank of the system and the order of the resulting dispersion relation require the simplification of the problem and the implication of approximate analysis methods. We use the Boussinesq approximation to simplify the expressions. The variable density with constant buoyancy frequency remains only in terms of large coefficients in our calculations. The assumption of low viscosity allows us to apply the theory of singular perturbations. The complete solution to the dispersion equation includes regular terms that characterize waves and singular terms that describe ligaments. Comparison of the precise and asymptotic solutions reveals their good agreement. Neglesting the heterogeneity and viscosity of the medium, we obtain known solutions. At the same time, the quality of the reduced expressions is decreased as far as in a homogeneous medium without dissipation the whole class of singular solutions, and the mathematical description of ligaments are lost. Constructed complete solutions of linearized periodic motion problem in heterogeneous media can be used to solve the problems of wave generation and other components of flows with physically justified initial and boundary conditions.
Gerstner F. Theorie der wellen. Annale Der Physik,1809,2(12):412-445. DOI:10.1002/andp.18090320808.
Abrashkin A A, Pelinovsky E N. Gerstner waves and their generalizations in hydrodynamics and geophysics. Physics-Uspekhi,2022,65:453-467. DOI:10.3367/UFNe.2021.05.038980.
Franklin B. Behavior of oil on water. Letter to J. Pringle.in Experiments and Observations on Electricity. London: Butterworth,1769:142-144.
Burnside W. On the small wave motions of a heterogeneous fluid under gravity. Proceedings of the London Mathematical Society,1889,s1-20(1):392-397. DOI:10.1112/plms/s1-20.1.392.
Love A E H. Wave motion in a heterogeneous heavy liquid. Proceedings of the London Mathematical Society.1890,s1-22(1):307-316. DOI:10.1112/plms/s1-22.1.307.
Lamb H. On atmospheric oscillations. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A, Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character.1911,84(574):551-572.http://www.jstor.org/stable/93330.
Horace Lamb F R S. XLIV. On waves due to a travelling disturbance,with an application to waves in superposed fluids. The London, Edinburgh,and Dublin Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science,1916,31(184):386-399. DOI:10.1080/14786440408635511.
Ekman V. W. On dead-water. The Norwegian North Polar Expedition 1893-1896 Scientific Results,1904,5(15): I-X,1-152, Plates I-XVI. DOI:10.5962/bhl.title.14631.
Rayleigh L. Investigation of the character of the equilibrium of an incompressible heavy fluid of variable density. Proceedings of the London Mathematical Society,1883,14:170-177. DOI:10.1112/plms/s1-14.1.170.
Vilho V. Uber die Wirkung der Windschwankungen auf die Pilotbeoachtungen. Societus Scientiarum Fennica Commentationes Physico-Mathematicae,1925,2(19):19-37.
Brunt D. The period of simple vertical oscillations in the atmosphere. Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society,1927,53(221):30-32. DOI:10.1002/qj.49705322103.
Lamb H. Treatise on the Motion of Fluids. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,1879:258.
Kochin N E, Kibel' I A, Roze I V. Teoreticheskaya gidromekhanika(Theoretical Fluid Mechanics). Moscow: Fizmatlit,1963.
Euler L. General laws of the motion of fluids. Proceedings of the Berlin Academy,1757,11:274-315.
Navier С. Mémoire sur les lois du mouvement des fluides. Royal Academie des Sciences,1822,6:389-440.
Stokes G G.3e.on the theories of the internal friction of fluids in motion,and of the equilibrium and motion of elastic bodies. In Classics of Elastic Wave Theory. Pelissier M A, Hoeber H,van de Coevering N,et al. Ed. Tulsa: Society of Exploration Geophysicists,2007. DOI:10.1190/1.9781560801931.ch3e.
Landau L D, Lifshitz E M. Fluid Mechanics. V.6. Course of Theoretical Physics. Oxford: Pergamon Press,1987.
Müller P. The Equations of Oceanic Motions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,2006.
Vallis G K. Atmospheric and Oceanic Fluid Dynamics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,2017.
Whitham G B. Linear and Nonlinear Waves. New York: John Wiley & Sons,1974.
Chandrasekhar S. Hydrodynamic and Hydromagnetic Stability. Oxford: Clarendon Press,1968.
Chashechkin Y D. Foundations of engineering mathematics applied for fluid flows. Axioms,2021,10(4):286. DOI:10.3390/axioms10040286.
Bender C M, Orszag S A. Advanced Mathematical Methods for Scientists and Engineers I: Asymptotic Methods and Perturbation Theory. New York: Springer Science & Business Media,2013.
Nayfeh A H. Introduction to Perturbation Techniques. New York: A Wiley-Interscience Publication,1981.
Chashechkin Y D, Ochirov A A. Periodic flows in a viscous stratified fluid in a homogeneous gravitational field. Mathematics,2023,11(21):4443. DOI:10.3390/math11214443.
Triveni B, Rao M V S, Gangadhar K,et al. Heat transfer analysis of MHD Casson nanofluid flow over a nonlinear stretching sheet in the presence of nonuniform heat source. Numerical Heat Transfer, Part A: Applications,2023,85(13):2145-2164. DOI:10.1080/10407782.2023.2219831.
Gangadhar K, Naga Chandrika G, Dinarvand S. Investigation into silver-engine oil nanoliquid convinced by Riga surface: Deviations in three binary nanofluids. Modern Physics Letters B,2025,39(1):2450385. DOI:10.1142/S0217984924503858.
Gangadhar K, Vardhana K A, Wakif A. HVAC-solar energy performance exploiting Sutterby(AA7075-Ag-Cu/C6H9NaO7)ternary magnetic nanofluid through spinning flow with joule heating. Modern Physics Letters B,2024:2450493. DOI:10.1142/S0217984924504931.
Gangadhar K, Sujana Sree T, Wakif A. Generalized slip impact of Casson nanofluid through cylinder implanted in swimming gyrotactic microorganisms. International Journal of Modern Physics B,2024,38(28):2450380. DOI:10.1142/S0217979224503806.
Gangadhar K, Rani M S, Wakif A. Ternary nanofluids due to moving wedge with strong magnetic field and convective condition. International Journal of Modern Physics B,2025,39(3):2550026. DOI:10.1142/S0217979225500262.
Gangadhar K, Sangeetha Rani M, Wakif A. Non-fourier heat flux and Joule dissipation in hybrid nanoparticles suspension with Williamson fluid. The European Physical Journal Plus,2024,139: DOI:10.1140/epjp/s13360-024-05054-w.
Rayleigh L. Some applications of photography. Nature,1891,44(1136):249-254. DOI:10.1038/044249e0.
Fedorov K N. The Thermohaline Fine Structure of the Ocean. Oxford: Pergamon Marine Series,1978.
US Standard Atmosphere,1976. NOAA-S/T-76-1562. NASA-TM-X-74335. Accession Number 77N16482.https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/19770009539.
Lighthill J. Waves in Fluids. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,1978.
Joseph D D. Domain perturbations: The higher order theory of infinitesimal water waves. Archive for Rational Mechanics and Analysis,1973,51(21):295-303. DOI:10.1007/BF00250536.
Sretenskii L N. Theory of Wave Motions in a Fluid. Moscow: Nauka,1977.
Ochirov A A, Chashechkin Y D. Two-dimensional surface periodic flows of an incompressible fluid in various models of the medium. Izvestiya, Atmospheric and Oceanic Physics,2024,60(1):1-14. DOI:10.1134/S0001433824700087.

LINKS